Trying to decide between Incogni vs DeleteMe? You’re not alone — these are the two most popular data removal services on the market, and choosing between them comes down to what matters most to you: price, coverage, monitoring frequency, or human oversight.
We’ve researched both services extensively. This guide breaks down exactly how they compare so you can make the right call for your situation.
The short answer: For most people, Incogni is the better value — it’s cheaper, covers more brokers, and monitors continuously. DeleteMe is better if you want human-reviewed removals and don’t mind paying more. Keep reading for the full breakdown.
Not sure you even need a service yet? Run a free Optery scan first to see how many data broker sites have your personal information. If you’re on 50+ sites (most people are), it’s time to take action.
Incogni vs DeleteMe: Quick Comparison
Here’s the side-by-side snapshot of Incogni vs DeleteMe:
| Feature | Incogni | DeleteMe |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Price | $77.88/year | $129/year |
| Monthly Price | $12.99/month | No monthly option |
| Price Difference | Incogni is $51.12/year cheaper | |
| Brokers Covered | 180+ | 86-101 automated |
| Monitoring | Continuous | Quarterly (every 3 months) |
| Human Review | No (fully automated) | Yes |
| Monthly Billing | Yes | No (annual only) |
| Free Scan | No | No |
| Dark Web Monitoring | No | No |
| Company | Surfshark (est. 2018) | Abine, Inc. (est. 2011) |
| Best For | Budget + wide coverage | Human oversight + reputation |
Now let’s dig into what each of these differences actually means for you.
Pricing: Incogni vs DeleteMe
The Incogni vs DeleteMe pricing comparison is straightforward — Incogni is significantly cheaper:
Incogni: $77.88/year ($6.49/month billed annually) or $12.99/month with no commitment.
DeleteMe: $129/year ($10.75/month billed annually). No monthly option — you have to pay the full year upfront.
That’s a $51.12 difference per year — Incogni costs about 40% less than DeleteMe for individual coverage.
For families, the gap widens. DeleteMe’s family plan (2 people) costs $229/year. Incogni doesn’t offer a formal family plan, but two individual annual subscriptions would cost $155.76 — still $73 cheaper than DeleteMe’s couple plan.
Winner: Incogni — significantly cheaper with the added flexibility of monthly billing.
Data Broker Coverage: Incogni vs DeleteMe
This is where the Incogni vs DeleteMe comparison gets interesting:
Incogni covers 180+ data brokers with fully automated scanning and removal. Every broker on their list gets continuous automated attention.
DeleteMe claims coverage of 750+ data broker sources, but the reality is more nuanced. Only about 86-101 of those get fully automated scanning and removal. The rest require you to use “custom removal requests” — and you only get 40-60 of those per year depending on your plan.
So while DeleteMe’s marketing number is bigger, Incogni actually automates removal from more brokers than DeleteMe does in practice. The sites that matter most — Whitepages, Spokeo, BeenVerified, TruePeopleSearch, and other high-traffic people search sites — are covered by both services.
Winner: Incogni — more brokers with fully automated removal. DeleteMe’s bigger headline number is misleading when you dig into how many are actually automated.
Monitoring Frequency: Incogni vs DeleteMe
This is one of the biggest practical differences in the Incogni vs DeleteMe debate:
Incogni monitors continuously. When a data broker re-lists your information (and they will — typically every 3-6 months), Incogni catches it and submits a fresh removal request promptly.
DeleteMe monitors quarterly — once every three months. That means your data could be re-listed the day after a scan and sit there exposed for up to 90 days before DeleteMe notices.
In a world where data brokers constantly re-scrape and republish your information, the difference between continuous and quarterly monitoring is significant. Three months is a long time for your home address and phone number to be publicly listed on people search sites.
Winner: Incogni — continuous monitoring catches re-listings much faster than quarterly scans.
Removal Approach: Automated vs Human Review
This is where DeleteMe has a genuine advantage in the Incogni vs DeleteMe comparison:
Incogni is fully automated. Algorithms handle the scanning, matching, and opt-out submissions. This keeps costs low and allows for continuous monitoring, but there’s no human checking the work.
DeleteMe uses a hybrid approach — automation combined with human researchers who review removal requests and verify results. This matters because some data brokers have intentionally complicated opt-out processes designed to trip up automated tools. Human eyes can catch things that bots miss.
After 15+ years in the business, DeleteMe has accumulated institutional knowledge about individual broker quirks — which ones need specific email formats, which ones try to make removal difficult, and how to navigate those obstacles. That experience is genuinely valuable for complicated cases.
Winner: DeleteMe — human review is a real advantage for stubborn data brokers and complicated data footprints. But for the average person with a standard data footprint, Incogni’s automation handles the job just fine.
Ease of Use: Incogni vs DeleteMe
Both services are designed to be hands-off, but there are differences:
Incogni setup takes about 3 minutes. Enter your personal details and the service starts working immediately. The dashboard is clean and shows removal progress in real time. Monthly billing means you can cancel anytime without losing a big upfront payment.
DeleteMe setup requires filling out a more detailed data sheet with names, addresses, phone numbers, and aliases (up to 6 of each). Your first privacy report arrives within 7 days. The dashboard is well-designed and easy to navigate, and you get a personal privacy advisor.
Both are genuinely easy to use. The main practical difference is that Incogni lets you start with monthly billing to test the service, while DeleteMe requires a full year commitment upfront.
Winner: Tie — both are simple to set up and use. Incogni gets a slight edge for monthly billing flexibility.
Reputation and Trust: Incogni vs DeleteMe
Incogni is made by Surfshark, an established cybersecurity company known for their VPN service. They have millions of users worldwide. Incogni launched in 2022 and has grown rapidly, but it’s a newer entrant in the data removal space.
DeleteMe has been operating since 2011 — making it one of the oldest data removal services in existence. It’s been recommended by the New York Times, PCMag (rated “Excellent”), and Wirecutter. They have a BBB A+ rating and over 400 reviews.
When it comes to pure track record and brand recognition, DeleteMe has the clear advantage. They’ve been doing this longer than anyone.
Winner: DeleteMe — 15 years of operation and major publication endorsements give them the edge on trust and reputation.
What About Optery?
Before you finalize the Incogni vs DeleteMe decision, it’s worth considering a third option: Optery.
Optery offers something neither Incogni nor DeleteMe has — a completely free scan that shows you exactly which data broker sites have your information before you pay anything. Their paid plans cover 350+ brokers (more than both Incogni and DeleteMe) with continuous monitoring.
Our recommendation: Start with Optery’s free scan regardless of which paid service you choose. It takes 30 seconds, costs nothing, and shows you the scope of the problem. Then you can make an informed decision about whether Incogni, DeleteMe, or Optery’s paid plan is the right fit.
For a full comparison of all three services plus others: Best Data Removal Services of 2026 (Compared).
Our Verdict: Incogni vs DeleteMe
After comparing every aspect of Incogni vs DeleteMe, here’s our recommendation:
Choose Incogni if you want:
- The most affordable option ($51/year cheaper than DeleteMe)
- More data brokers covered with full automation (180+ vs 86-101)
- Continuous monitoring instead of quarterly scans
- Monthly billing flexibility (try before committing to a year)
- A simple, hands-off experience
Choose DeleteMe if you want:
- Human-reviewed removal requests (better for complicated data footprints)
- The most established brand with 15+ years of experience
- Personal privacy advisor access
- Major publication endorsements (NYT, PCMag, Wirecutter)
For most people, Incogni is the better choice. It covers more brokers, monitors continuously, and costs significantly less. The only reason to choose DeleteMe over Incogni is if you specifically want human oversight or have a particularly complicated data footprint with many past names and addresses.
Either way, start by seeing how exposed you are: Run a free Optery scan to check how many data broker sites have your personal information right now.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Incogni or DeleteMe better?
For most people, Incogni is better — it’s cheaper ($77.88 vs $129/year), covers more brokers with automation (180+ vs 86-101), and monitors continuously instead of quarterly. DeleteMe is better if you specifically want human-reviewed removals.
Is Incogni cheaper than DeleteMe?
Yes. Incogni costs $77.88/year vs DeleteMe’s $129/year — a savings of $51.12 per year. Incogni also offers monthly billing at $12.99/month, while DeleteMe requires annual payment upfront. Full Incogni pricing breakdown.
Does Incogni cover more data brokers than DeleteMe?
Yes, in terms of fully automated removal. Incogni automates removal from 180+ brokers. DeleteMe claims 750+ sources but only automates removal from 86-101 — the rest require manual custom removal requests. Full DeleteMe details.
Does DeleteMe have human reviewers?
Yes — that’s DeleteMe’s main differentiator. Real people review removal requests and verify results, which can help with data brokers that have complicated opt-out processes. Incogni is fully automated with no human review.
Can I try Incogni for one month?
Yes. Incogni offers monthly billing at $12.99/month with no annual commitment. You can try it for a month and cancel if you’re not satisfied. DeleteMe requires a full year upfront with no monthly option.
Is there a better option than both?
Optery is worth considering — it covers 350+ brokers (more than both), offers a free scan, and was ranked #1 most effective by Consumer Reports. See our full comparison of all services.
Do I really need a data removal service?
If your personal information is on data broker sites — and it almost certainly is — then yes. Your exposed data leads to spam calls, identity theft risk, doxxing vulnerability, and junk mail. Run a free Optery scan to see how exposed you are.
This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure for details.